As the party-goers wait excitedly to ring in the New Year, London admist to Matteo that she's had feelings for him since they met. But just as they get closer, a ghost from Matteo's past threatens to ruin everything. Meanwhile, Efrain and Elias let loose with Kari and Amber, but when Efrain catches a glimps of Elias falling into temptation, he runs from the party. In the hallway, Elias shows Efrain that their Good Light is still bright and strong. On their way back to Kari's, the boys disappear.